I am looking for a highly-rated all-season set. The main consideration is better tire wear, then to a lesser degree snow handling ability.

My rear OEM S02's lasted 10k miles, then my second rear Yokos also lasted only 10k. The Pirelli P Zero Nero M+S look good for the rear (245/50 WR16 SL), but I don't see a well-rated Pirelli pair for the front.

Is it okay to mix mfrs on the front and rear? Also, anyone have suggestions for a good all-season set?

John:

 

First, don't mix tires. It's been discussed here many times (you can do a search) and not considered a good idea.

Second, all seasons won't be enough in snow. If you plan to drive the S in VT winter then you need a set of 4 winter tires like the Blizzak LM-22, Pirelli 210, etc. You may even consider hardcore snow tires like the WS-50 or Toyo Garit HT, depending on how well the streets are cleared in your area.