Are RPMs Why Our Cars Are Inefficient?
#31
Originally Posted by moogleii,Nov 17 2009, 02:20 PM
I'm not sure why you're getting so many defensive responses, but i'm pretty sure the answer is "yes."
If we had a taller 6, we'd get more mpg. Once you're cruising, you don't even need to be at peak torque, either. It would suck at the track though.
And yaeh, cutting your cruise speed would help greatly. I cruise at 80-85, and my mileage is about 20-21 (well, with mixed driving, I have no huge commutes).
If we had a taller 6, we'd get more mpg. Once you're cruising, you don't even need to be at peak torque, either. It would suck at the track though.
And yaeh, cutting your cruise speed would help greatly. I cruise at 80-85, and my mileage is about 20-21 (well, with mixed driving, I have no huge commutes).
Ralleh, one thing worth noting that has not yet been discussed is that the angle of our windshields is unusually steep. This is due to several factors you can look up (safety being one of them). Aerodynamics have an exponential relationship in top speed etc. functions. With our unusually steep windshield, it is quite possible that cruising at "sports car" speeds of say 80-85 really degrades fuel mileage.
Another is that as you reach the peak of any engine's output capacity, fuel mileage tends to decrease slightly beyond just a linear relationship with the horsepower gained.
Whether it's due to excessive heat, higher compression, the tighter gearing used in most of the aforementioned, is not always consistent.
Overall, you ask a decent question. I've wondered the same thing when you see EPA estimates of 26mpg highway for a 2900 lbs 2.0 ltr 240hp/160tq honda and 29mpg highway for a 4400 lbs 4.6 ltr nearly 400hp/400+tq lexus barge.
The excellent aero's, gearing, and relatively little output in proportion to max output needed to sustain highway speeds of the c6 supports the above argument as well.
#32
Registered User
Here is honda's except on the s2000:
At first sight of the S2000 you feel a connection. A connection to Honda's long heritage of racing success on the world's most demanding circuits, to the 70 Grand Prix victories in Formula 1 and the 65 victories in CART. That's because the S2000 wasn't just "inspired" by racing, it was fine-tuned by Honda's racing engineers on the high-speed straightaways, breathtaking sweepers and tight hairpins of Suzuka. You'll feel the S2000's racing pedigree the moment you slip behind the wheel. The gauges and controls are prominent and logically placed, creating an intuitive driver interface that's intimate, yet comfortable. High-bolstered perforated leather seats cradle and brace you for quick manoeuvres, while the audio system with speakers behind the headrest provides the ideal soundtrack for your drive. As the bright digital tach arcs rapidly clockwise, you get an advanced lesson in acceleration. And the harder you push the S2000, with its new Drive-by-Wire Throttle System™, the more you realize this car was built to respond.
Here is the except on the Insight:
The 2010 Honda Insight. Yes it's a hybrid. But beyond its ultra low emissions, fuel efficiency and fun-to-drive nature, its unique Eco Assist™ system with ECON mode can actually make you a more environmentally friendly driver. Moreover, the Insight represents another innovative step that we can all take towards a brighter future with blue skies for our children.
The Insight's unique ECO Assist™ technology modifies various vehicle systems to minimize your overall energy use and maximize your fuel efficiency – all at the push of the ECON button. Plus with the Eco Guide feedback system, the Insight actually encourages you to become a more fuel-efficient driver. The system monitors your immediate driving habits and shows you how efficiently you are accelerating, braking, or cruising by changing the speedometer background colour from blue to green. The Eco Guide also features a long term cumulative scoring system located in your Multi-Information Display that rewards you with green "leaves" as your driving performance improves overtime.
Maybe you thought you bought a Insight?
At first sight of the S2000 you feel a connection. A connection to Honda's long heritage of racing success on the world's most demanding circuits, to the 70 Grand Prix victories in Formula 1 and the 65 victories in CART. That's because the S2000 wasn't just "inspired" by racing, it was fine-tuned by Honda's racing engineers on the high-speed straightaways, breathtaking sweepers and tight hairpins of Suzuka. You'll feel the S2000's racing pedigree the moment you slip behind the wheel. The gauges and controls are prominent and logically placed, creating an intuitive driver interface that's intimate, yet comfortable. High-bolstered perforated leather seats cradle and brace you for quick manoeuvres, while the audio system with speakers behind the headrest provides the ideal soundtrack for your drive. As the bright digital tach arcs rapidly clockwise, you get an advanced lesson in acceleration. And the harder you push the S2000, with its new Drive-by-Wire Throttle System™, the more you realize this car was built to respond.
Here is the except on the Insight:
The 2010 Honda Insight. Yes it's a hybrid. But beyond its ultra low emissions, fuel efficiency and fun-to-drive nature, its unique Eco Assist™ system with ECON mode can actually make you a more environmentally friendly driver. Moreover, the Insight represents another innovative step that we can all take towards a brighter future with blue skies for our children.
The Insight's unique ECO Assist™ technology modifies various vehicle systems to minimize your overall energy use and maximize your fuel efficiency – all at the push of the ECON button. Plus with the Eco Guide feedback system, the Insight actually encourages you to become a more fuel-efficient driver. The system monitors your immediate driving habits and shows you how efficiently you are accelerating, braking, or cruising by changing the speedometer background colour from blue to green. The Eco Guide also features a long term cumulative scoring system located in your Multi-Information Display that rewards you with green "leaves" as your driving performance improves overtime.
Maybe you thought you bought a Insight?
#35
Face it. this car was designed with performance in mind, not economy. you could juggle gear ratios, but that could get costly. not sure what would be a good solution for your quest for better mileage. but if you find one, post it. i'm sure others with the same delima would like to know. good luck!
#36
Registered User
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Lexington Park, MD
Posts: 438
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by YELLOW JACKET,Nov 17 2009, 07:31 PM
Face it. this car was designed with performance in mind, not economy. you could juggle gear ratios, but that could get costly. not sure what would be a good solution for your quest for better mileage. but if you find one, post it. i'm sure others with the same delima would like to know. good luck!
Sorry but this guy seems hung up on gearing even though other logical reasoning behind the poor gas mileage has been discussed.
It sounds to me, and I could be wrong, that he sees the car as inefficient simply because of the gas mileage. This is just not the type of efficiency honda had in mind when designing the S. They were focused on efficiency in terms of power output for a NA 2.0 L or 2.2L 4 cylinder engine.
The aerodynamics were sacrificed for safety because the engineers considered safety to be a higher priority than gas mileage.
In the end this question being asked is just simply a result of, the car wasn't built for that.
#38
Registered User
it's not simple to swap a 1st and 6th gear from one tranny to a different tranny (i'm talking about ap1 to ap2, not ap1 to ap1). the relationships between the gears are more complex than 1->2->3, etc. (AFAIK)
you would most likely end up spending so much time/money on that pursuit, that it would almost assuredly end up being cheaper to buy some custom tranny with the ratios you think you want.
the more "efficient" way of doing what you kind of want would be to have 2 differentials. one with normal final drive for normal driving, and one with a "lower" (say 3.10 instead of 4.10) final drive for long trips.
you would most likely end up spending so much time/money on that pursuit, that it would almost assuredly end up being cheaper to buy some custom tranny with the ratios you think you want.
the more "efficient" way of doing what you kind of want would be to have 2 differentials. one with normal final drive for normal driving, and one with a "lower" (say 3.10 instead of 4.10) final drive for long trips.
#39
Hypothetical situation
You get 25mpg stock.
You swap tranny bits to get 30 mpg (unlikely)
Assuming gas prices are $2.50/gallon. After 25,000 miles, you'd save just over $400. That'd barely cover the cost of the Ap2 tranny, much less the effort you'd put into it.
This whole discussion has been beaten to death. If you do that much highway driving and care *that much* about gas mileage, get a beater car.
You get 25mpg stock.
You swap tranny bits to get 30 mpg (unlikely)
Assuming gas prices are $2.50/gallon. After 25,000 miles, you'd save just over $400. That'd barely cover the cost of the Ap2 tranny, much less the effort you'd put into it.
This whole discussion has been beaten to death. If you do that much highway driving and care *that much* about gas mileage, get a beater car.
#40
Registered User
Originally Posted by spectacle,Nov 17 2009, 11:47 AM
Want to see how much better your gas mileage will be if you cruised 6th gear at 2k RPM? Get on the hwy and try it.
Originally Posted by moogleii,Nov 17 2009, 02:20 PM
And yaeh, cutting your cruise speed would help greatly. I cruise at 80-85, and my mileage is about 20-21 (well, with mixed driving, I have no huge commutes).
Originally Posted by bluAP1s2k,Nov 17 2009, 07:51 PM
It sounds to me, and I could be wrong, that he sees the car as inefficient simply because of the gas mileage. This is just not the type of efficiency honda had in mind when designing the S. They were focused on efficiency in terms of power output for a NA 2.0 L or 2.2L 4 cylinder engine.