over reved in nuetral with cruise control anyone?
#11
Originally Posted by Gigdy,Nov 30 2009, 06:18 AM
Why is this a bug? The car has no idea what gear it is in. All it knows is that it is slowing down and needs to accelerate.
You are probably right that the car does not know if the it's actually in gear. But in the case of the the OP, once the car is in neutral the ecu should sample engine speed and delay the engagement of cruise control if RPM is rapidly falling and if it proceeds to stay at idle range withing a second or two then disable the engagement altogether. This should be a straight forward implementation in software/firmware since the fix does not require new hardware.
BTW, your scenario is also true when you step on the brakes. The designer got it right here and disables cruise control.
#12
Moderator
Originally Posted by dhean,Dec 1 2009, 12:17 AM
"Bug" in terms of system bug wherein the system engineers did not completely think of the possible scenarios and impose the appropriate requirements.
You are probably right that the car does not know if the it's actually in gear. But in the case of the the OP, once the car is in neutral the ecu should sample engine speed and delay the engagement of cruise control if RPM is rapidly falling and if it proceeds to stay at idle range withing a second or two then disable the engagement altogether. This should be a straight forward implementation in software/firmware since the fix does not require new hardware.
BTW, your scenario is also true when you step on the brakes. The designer got it right here and disables cruise control.
You are probably right that the car does not know if the it's actually in gear. But in the case of the the OP, once the car is in neutral the ecu should sample engine speed and delay the engagement of cruise control if RPM is rapidly falling and if it proceeds to stay at idle range withing a second or two then disable the engagement altogether. This should be a straight forward implementation in software/firmware since the fix does not require new hardware.
BTW, your scenario is also true when you step on the brakes. The designer got it right here and disables cruise control.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post