Clutch slipped on launch vs. F355
#11
This car is not designed to take clutch drops. Very few cars take clutch dumps well ... it's just a bad idea all around. The rear tires are very difficult to spin and something else will give. Typically it's the diff or CV joints. Not cheap.
If you want to get out of the hole faster ... get a lower ratio in the rear end. Additionally, Ganley Honda states the '04 housing is superior to the earlier year model diff housings and incorporated some of the mods Comptech uses in their diff housing + larger oiling channels. The Comptech is still a stronger housing though, but the '04 housing is a great comprimise though.
If you want to get out of the hole faster ... get a lower ratio in the rear end. Additionally, Ganley Honda states the '04 housing is superior to the earlier year model diff housings and incorporated some of the mods Comptech uses in their diff housing + larger oiling channels. The Comptech is still a stronger housing though, but the '04 housing is a great comprimise though.
#12
Having said that this was the first time you've "dumped" the clutch, I am tending to think that your interpretation of "dumping the clutch" or "dropping the clutch" is not what you think it is and you did it incorrectly. There is many examples of people with NA cars and S/C'd cars with and without "gears" having "launched" their cars hundreds of times and have logged tens of thousands of miles on the original clutch without issue to any of the their drivetrains. Then, I've heard of many people, who after a few clutch dumps, have totally Bar-B-Q'd their clutches and fried their diffs. Done correctly and with the proper knowledge of powertrain mechanics, you "could" do it repeatedly. Done wrong, it only takes once to break something. Please don't take these statements as my way of telling you that it's OK to now go out and practice doing clutch dumps till you get it right. This is NOT the car to figure out how to do it right.
Insofar as getting a stronger clutch, again, if it is used in the proper manner, whether it be "dropping" or not dropping, it will less impact to the rest of the drivetrain that you may think. If you are already doing it wrong, then having a stronger clutch might be of some assistance to you in "slipping" the clutch to get that better take off OR, it may be all it takes for you to break something even faster.
Regarding the Comptech "reinforced" housing, it is not a stronger "housing". It is a kit that comprises of stronger ends caps and carrier bolts. The housing as such, is not any stronger than before. The OEM '04 housing, on the other hand, is made of stouter stuff.
Insofar as getting a stronger clutch, again, if it is used in the proper manner, whether it be "dropping" or not dropping, it will less impact to the rest of the drivetrain that you may think. If you are already doing it wrong, then having a stronger clutch might be of some assistance to you in "slipping" the clutch to get that better take off OR, it may be all it takes for you to break something even faster.
Regarding the Comptech "reinforced" housing, it is not a stronger "housing". It is a kit that comprises of stronger ends caps and carrier bolts. The housing as such, is not any stronger than before. The OEM '04 housing, on the other hand, is made of stouter stuff.
#14
Originally posted by xviper
The OEM '04 housing, on the other hand, is made of stouter stuff.
The OEM '04 housing, on the other hand, is made of stouter stuff.
any more new info on this yet? how much stronger than the older diff?
#17
I don't remember what it is made of. I think it is still aluminum. As for if it is compatable with older models, this question was asked before but I don't think anyone really knew the answer. I don't believe anyone has tried one yet.
#19
Jeff at Ganley Honda offers the '04 housing as an alternative to the Comptech reinforced when they set up the gear swap (via Rick's site). I put in my order today for the 4.57 gear set ... the '04 bolts right up. I believe the front part of the housing is a cast ferrous metal (probably iron). The rear cover is aluminium. The total unit is heavy!