Broken U-Joint
07-20-2005, 05:09 AM
#1
Thread Starter
Broken U-Joint
Thought I would post this here, since I don't know how this problem happened. I was driving through the mountains of WV last weekend when a loud whirring noise started. I had to drive the car to my destination since I was in the middle of nowhere. Fortunately, it was only about 20 miles to get there. When I stopped the car, it was no longer drivable, since something was clunking against the steering column. I did get in six hours of very fun mountain twisties beforehand. 
I had to flatbed the car back to DC (250 miles) and it's at the dealer now being fixed. I lucked out since my insurance paid for the tow and my extended warranty is paying all but $100 of the cost to fix it. The technician says it's a broken U-joint in the drive shaft. There is no dispute about fixing it - I was just wondering whether anyone else has had this problem. Haven't read about it anywhere.
I had to flatbed the car back to DC (250 miles) and it's at the dealer now being fixed. I lucked out since my insurance paid for the tow and my extended warranty is paying all but $100 of the cost to fix it. The technician says it's a broken U-joint in the drive shaft. There is no dispute about fixing it - I was just wondering whether anyone else has had this problem. Haven't read about it anywhere.
07-20-2005, 07:53 AM
#2
Ms P, you probably want to move this to "UTH", rather than "Technical", You'll be much more likely to get a response there (This is only the 2nd post here in 3 days). And I think I did read a thread about a broken U joint not too long ago, maybe in the "Competition" forum, not sure though. It's not a common failure judging by the fact I only remember reading about one. You must drive like an animal!! 
Glad it's sorted out. I don't see how it could have been clunking against your steering column though.. Hopefully someone with more knowledge will chime in.
Cheers, Mike
Glad it's sorted out. I don't see how it could have been clunking against your steering column though.. Hopefully someone with more knowledge will chime in.
Cheers, Mike
07-20-2005, 07:59 AM
#3
Thread Starter
Yeah, you might be right...I thought of that. But I can't move it myself. Mods - move this to UTH for me? Thanks.
07-20-2005, 04:19 PM
#4
Originally Posted by MsPerky,Jul 20 2005, 06:09 AM
since something was clunking against the steering column.
The technician says it's a broken U-joint in the drive shaft.
The technician says it's a broken U-joint in the drive shaft.
The above quoted lines is a bit confusing. First, that business about something clunking against the steering column would suggest that it has something to do with the "U-joint" in the steering column. This would indicate that the locking bolt sheared off or fell off and the U-joint uncoupled.
We don't have true "U-joints" in the drive shaft (or "propeller" shaft in our case). The other joints that are in the 1/2 shafts are CV type joints. If any of these go, your steering would still function normally. The car just won't move.
The steering U-joint is not a common fault. The prop shaft joints rarely go. The CVs, however, have been known to go bad, but usually with much more abuse than what I can imagine that you would put your car through.
07-20-2005, 04:33 PM
#5
Thread Starter
Hmmmm...well that description was mine. I could steer the car but there was something clunking when it went forward, so I barely moved it, only to park it, then drive it onto the edge of the tow truck bed. Then when we got back here, I drove it a few yards at the dealership. My dealer rep said the technician told him it was a broken U-joint, so I'm taking his word for it. When I pick up the car, I'll check further on the details. Thanks, Dave.
07-20-2005, 05:33 PM
#6
Originally Posted by MsPerky,Jul 20 2005, 05:33 PM
Hmmmm...well that description was mine. I could steer the car but there was something clunking when it went forward, so I barely moved it, only to park it, then drive it onto the edge of the tow truck bed. Then when we got back here, I drove it a few yards at the dealership. My dealer rep said the technician told him it was a broken U-joint, so I'm taking his word for it. When I pick up the car, I'll check further on the details. Thanks, Dave.
07-21-2005, 02:20 AM
#7
Thread Starter
OK...I'm going to check on exactly which joint it is. Maybe the technician has his terms mixed up. Thanks again, Dave.
Trending Topics
07-21-2005, 10:07 AM
#9
I just replaced my propeller shaft (drive shaft) because of a noisy CV joint at the rear. It could be that the mechanic just used the term "u-joint" because most cars use u-joints on the drive shaft.
Mine made some loud clicking noises several months ago then promptly went away (healed itself). Just recently I had the car up in the air and when spinning the prop shaft by hand or with the engine it sounded like there were loose marbles in it. Yikes! So I got a replacement at a junk yard ($175), verified the CV's were OK, and replaced it.
Don't know why it failed (at only 146k), but the grease in the rear CV was cooked and very dry and crumbly, front looked OK. Shame you can't replace the CV's by themselves.
Mine made some loud clicking noises several months ago then promptly went away (healed itself). Just recently I had the car up in the air and when spinning the prop shaft by hand or with the engine it sounded like there were loose marbles in it. Yikes! So I got a replacement at a junk yard ($175), verified the CV's were OK, and replaced it.
Don't know why it failed (at only 146k), but the grease in the rear CV was cooked and very dry and crumbly, front looked OK. Shame you can't replace the CV's by themselves.
07-21-2005, 10:35 AM
#10
Thread Starter
^ Yeah, I have a feeling you are right and he just misnamed it. Ah, so the whole propeller shaft has to be replaced, not just the CV joints. Learning new stuff here.