Cruising gear
#21
Originally Posted by Elistan,Jul 25 2010, 10:32 AM
Source?
My understanding is that with lower revs, and slightly wider throttle openings to achieve necessary cruising power, you get less restriction for airflow entering the engine, as well as more complete combustion of the fuel, and therefore get better fuel economy. I'd love to read of empirical studies showing otherwise, though.
Anyway, back to the OP's question - personally, at 35mph, hmm, I'm probably 4th gear more often than 3rd, but not exclusively so.
My understanding is that with lower revs, and slightly wider throttle openings to achieve necessary cruising power, you get less restriction for airflow entering the engine, as well as more complete combustion of the fuel, and therefore get better fuel economy. I'd love to read of empirical studies showing otherwise, though.
Anyway, back to the OP's question - personally, at 35mph, hmm, I'm probably 4th gear more often than 3rd, but not exclusively so.
The lower the RPM with the wider throttle opening = most efficient? I'd really like to learn more about this...interesting.
#23
Originally Posted by JLUDE,Jul 26 2010, 09:06 AM
My own findings over the years? I get 28-30 mpg city and 33-34 highway in my AP1 and I never let the RPMs fall below 3,000 once rolling. If I'm doing it wrong I should be getting crappy MPG's.
The lower the RPM with the wider throttle opening = most efficient? I'd really like to learn more about this...interesting.
The lower the RPM with the wider throttle opening = most efficient? I'd really like to learn more about this...interesting.
i get like 22-23 mpg combined in NYC with maybe 1/2 city (including frequent stopping from traffic lights, stop signs, etc) and 1/2 highway and i vtec everyday. i'm not complaining about this number either cause i'd like to see a 350z/g35 get these kind of numbers with same driving style.
back on topic, i shift around 2500-3500 usually depending on how fast i want to go. i don't know about ap1's but ap2's are pretty good even at 2500 rpm.
#24
I agree. City I am lucky to get 23, more like 20 if I am doing ANY acceleration and run the AC. Highway i have hit 30 before, top up cruising at around 75.
For 35mph, I would be in 4th or 5th, depending on grade.
For 35mph, I would be in 4th or 5th, depending on grade.
#26
Originally Posted by JLUDE,Jul 26 2010, 05:06 AM
The lower the RPM with the wider throttle opening = most efficient? I'd really like to learn more about this...interesting.
The AP2 S2000 will pull from around 1500 RPM and you can shift by 2000 RPM, as long as you're not in a hurry. Not saying this is a fun way to drive the car, but it will yield the best mileage. AP1s probably need a few more revs.
As for individual results, tires make a huge difference. No one is getting 30 MPG with a set of Dunlop Star Specs regardless of how they drive, but if you have hard tires, it's easy to top 30 MPG.
#27
^that's interesting, i didn't know there was a theory behind all this.
so what you're saying is, when i start off the line, go WOT until it reaches around 2500 rpm (don't think i could shift at 2k), shift until i hit the highest gear right? pretty much avoid holding the throttle in lightly, especially when i'm driving on highway? this is completely opposite of what i've been doing but if it works i'm willing to try it.
so what you're saying is, when i start off the line, go WOT until it reaches around 2500 rpm (don't think i could shift at 2k), shift until i hit the highest gear right? pretty much avoid holding the throttle in lightly, especially when i'm driving on highway? this is completely opposite of what i've been doing but if it works i'm willing to try it.
#28
Originally Posted by Elistan,Jul 25 2010, 01:32 PM
Source?
My understanding is that with lower revs, and slightly wider throttle openings to achieve necessary cruising power, you get less restriction for airflow entering the engine, as well as more complete combustion of the fuel, and therefore get better fuel economy. I'd love to read of empirical studies showing otherwise, though.
Anyway, back to the OP's question - personally, at 35mph, hmm, I'm probably 4th gear more often than 3rd, but not exclusively so.
My understanding is that with lower revs, and slightly wider throttle openings to achieve necessary cruising power, you get less restriction for airflow entering the engine, as well as more complete combustion of the fuel, and therefore get better fuel economy. I'd love to read of empirical studies showing otherwise, though.
Anyway, back to the OP's question - personally, at 35mph, hmm, I'm probably 4th gear more often than 3rd, but not exclusively so.
#29
Originally Posted by thomsbrain,Jul 25 2010, 07:21 PM
This is categorically false.
Engines are most efficient at the lowest possible RPM and the widest possible throttle opening.
As for me, 6th gear by 35 MPH.
Engines are most efficient at the lowest possible RPM and the widest possible throttle opening.
As for me, 6th gear by 35 MPH.
RPM has NOTHING to do with gas use. I've done 8500 rpm without using ANY gas.
#30
Originally Posted by thomsbrain,Jul 26 2010, 01:09 PM
Lower RPMs minimize friction losses, wider throttle openings minimize pumping losses. The hypermilers in their first-gen Insights and manual first-gen Civics generally go full throttle to about 2000 RPM and then shift. The goal is to get into top gear as soon as possible. It's also why the "pulse and glide" technique yields better mileage than steady-throttle cruising, because you basically run the throttle in two modes: fully open and completely off, which minimizes pumping losses.
The AP2 S2000 will pull from around 1500 RPM and you can shift by 2000 RPM, as long as you're not in a hurry. Not saying this is a fun way to drive the car, but it will yield the best mileage. AP1s probably need a few more revs.
As for individual results, tires make a huge difference. No one is getting 30 MPG with a set of Dunlop Star Specs regardless of how they drive, but if you have hard tires, it's easy to top 30 MPG.
The AP2 S2000 will pull from around 1500 RPM and you can shift by 2000 RPM, as long as you're not in a hurry. Not saying this is a fun way to drive the car, but it will yield the best mileage. AP1s probably need a few more revs.
As for individual results, tires make a huge difference. No one is getting 30 MPG with a set of Dunlop Star Specs regardless of how they drive, but if you have hard tires, it's easy to top 30 MPG.
Say to came to a light on a 50mph blvd. You are at a standstill, and need to get back up to 50. If you do it your way (shift at 3000 rpm to get to top gear quickly), you will press the gas pedal HARDER, thus your TPS will open the injectors more, meaning, more fuel.
This is assuming you want to get up to 50 in the same amount of time. You can do it your way, with 1/4 throttle, but it will take you a mile to hit 50.