A weird story happened to me again
#1
A weird story happened to me again
So after my sad experience about the minimal power gain i got over my "costly parts" and the expensive AEM EMS tuning, i decided to go from J's 60RS to 70RS to pick up some more power. my butt dyno telling me YES it feels faster at mid range but i'm not sure. i also ask around and found out i should get a 70mm test pipe instead of my 63mm so i did so. i went to a dyno shop to prove if the 70RS and 70 test pipe help. the 70RS HAD BEEN INSTALLED before i went to dyno today. so the MAIN THING im talking about is the test pipe.
i dynoed a base run before i put the 70 test pipe on (J's intake, T1R header (65mm collector), 63mm TP, 70RS)
and then i got 211whp and 147tq (corrected). it was almost identical as the 60RS i had before.....the dyno runs at the same dyno system (dynojet) but different shops and time. so i started to have a bad feel about the test pipe.
then we put the 70 TP on and dyno again. now we were all shocked. the peak power loses about 0.5 (210.5) but there were 4whp and 4tq lost between 5k and 6k rpm. and overall the curve is sightly lower than the base run (63 TP), i say about 0.5-1 whp and tq.
i talked to the people at shop and we couldn't find out the answer because it just doesn't any sense to me nor you guys i think. im totally lost and depressed by what i recently did and spent on my car just feel like i throw $$ to get power lost.
so 65-63-70 makes more power than 65-70-70. RIDICULOUS! can anyone explain this to me? again i will post up my dyno
i dynoed a base run before i put the 70 test pipe on (J's intake, T1R header (65mm collector), 63mm TP, 70RS)
and then i got 211whp and 147tq (corrected). it was almost identical as the 60RS i had before.....the dyno runs at the same dyno system (dynojet) but different shops and time. so i started to have a bad feel about the test pipe.
then we put the 70 TP on and dyno again. now we were all shocked. the peak power loses about 0.5 (210.5) but there were 4whp and 4tq lost between 5k and 6k rpm. and overall the curve is sightly lower than the base run (63 TP), i say about 0.5-1 whp and tq.
i talked to the people at shop and we couldn't find out the answer because it just doesn't any sense to me nor you guys i think. im totally lost and depressed by what i recently did and spent on my car just feel like i throw $$ to get power lost.
so 65-63-70 makes more power than 65-70-70. RIDICULOUS! can anyone explain this to me? again i will post up my dyno
#2
Registered User
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Augusta, GA
Posts: 1,043
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That just seems odd to me...I'm putting my 70mm test pipe on today. I'm tempted to get a dyno done sometime this week if I can just to see where my numbers would compare with yours. My mods would be a berk 70mm test pipe, 70mm invidia single with a stock header/intake. What kinds of dyno was this done on again? I cant remember.
#4
Former Moderator
That's really baffling. But you should always do your tuning on the exact same dyno as the baseline. Even though it is the same brand of dyno, the calibration is going to be different.
#5
any chance of exhaust leak? you prob need to stick to one dyno and stay there. maybe get a re tune with another reputable shop for a second opinion of some sort. id lose the header.
NA has never been about gaining the most top end. its about evening up the power band. our car has enough top end power. we need low end torque.
if i were you.. i do go back to stock.. dyno.. then go piece by piece. a lot of dyno time but if this is what your worried about then its worth it.
NA has never been about gaining the most top end. its about evening up the power band. our car has enough top end power. we need low end torque.
if i were you.. i do go back to stock.. dyno.. then go piece by piece. a lot of dyno time but if this is what your worried about then its worth it.
#7
Originally Posted by superpirate,Jun 7 2009, 05:57 AM
That just seems odd to me...I'm putting my 70mm test pipe on today. I'm tempted to get a dyno done sometime this week if I can just to see where my numbers would compare with yours. My mods would be a berk 70mm test pipe, 70mm invidia single with a stock header/intake. What kinds of dyno was this done on again? I cant remember.
Trending Topics
#8
Originally Posted by negcamber,Jun 7 2009, 09:59 AM
That's really baffling. But you should always do your tuning on the exact same dyno as the baseline. Even though it is the same brand of dyno, the calibration is going to be different.
#9
Originally Posted by the s2k dude,Jun 7 2009, 11:23 AM
any chance of exhaust leak? you prob need to stick to one dyno and stay there. maybe get a re tune with another reputable shop for a second opinion of some sort. id lose the header.
NA has never been about gaining the most top end. its about evening up the power band. our car has enough top end power. we need low end torque.
if i were you.. i do go back to stock.. dyno.. then go piece by piece. a lot of dyno time but if this is what your worried about then its worth it.
NA has never been about gaining the most top end. its about evening up the power band. our car has enough top end power. we need low end torque.
if i were you.. i do go back to stock.. dyno.. then go piece by piece. a lot of dyno time but if this is what your worried about then its worth it.