Estimated Manheim auction prices for next week (calculated using completed transactions from the past two months) for a '95 Civic EX Coupe automatic with 160k miles:
Above: $2,100
Avergae: $1,325
Below: $575 (cars sold at "below" price are pretty beat up)

Estimated retail:
Above: $2,775
Average: $1,950
Below: $1,125

Sounds like the car you're looking at falls slightly above average. You might be able to knock off a couple $100 but doesn't sound like a bad deal as it is.

 

I am assuming it is a manual.... there is no definite price on a car like this nowadays especially with high gas prices..

I was in the market for a similar car few months back...i wanted a sedan and saw
94 ex 5spd good condition 134k $4500
92 lx fair condition 160k $2300
95si coupe fair condition a lil riced out parts 140k $4800
93 dx fair condition 208k $1500

I waited and waited and finally bought a 92 EX fair condition 110k $1600... it needed a midpipe,an axle, a few bulbs and the VSS conked out last week 100 fix...

I say it is a supply demand thing.....

GL