yep, both cars are heavy, but I'd take the M3 over the S4...now where is the RS4???

 

M3... Its more of a "drivers" or racers car.. It rev's higher, and the connection to the road feel is what your looking for in a sports car. You dont wanta car that drives you .. I can tell your into sports cars since your on this forum considering the s2000 being a RAW sports car. Go with the m3... I'll trust BMW or AUDI ANYDAY!!!!

 

If I had to choose between the two, an M3. But I wouldn't own either.

 

If you need the 4-doors I'd get the S4, if not it's a toss up. I have a B5 S4 and it's great for modding. The B6 V-8 is so-so for modding since there are no turbos to tweak. I think in the end if you want a highstrung razor-sharp handling car I'd go with the M3. If you want a livable everyday 4-door sports car with all-wheel drive bad weather handling I'd get the S4.

Sam

 

Can't wait until the RS4 hits the states. I'll have one of these and one of those.

 

Maybe this will help.

Top Gear - M3 vs S4

Yes it's a zip file that contains the wmv